Scrubs is a show that I initially started watching, but my interest soon drifted and I just didn’t stick with it. Zach Braff, however, always struck me as someone who was intelligent and had a good sense of humour. Garden State, from 2004, was his first go at filling the three roles of writer/director/actor, and he’s managed to create a film that is both interesting and creative without being self-conscious.
Andrew Largeman (Braff) is a prisoner of his medicated state, feeling neither the highs nor lows of ordinary life. The film opens on an aeroplane, the passengers in a state of panic as the plane rocks and dips, but Largeman remains unaffected. Physically, he is present in his life, but emotionally, he is disconnected — when his mother dies suddenly, even relative strangers express more emotion about the event.
As Roger Ebert points out in his review, the parallels to Mike Nichols’ The Graduate are unmistakeable (and coincidentally, Natalie Portman stars in both Garden State and Nichols’ recent film adaptation of the play Closer). Largeman, like Benjamin in The Graduate, returns home as a detached, passive observer of the world around him. The classic scene of Benjamin at the bottom of the pool was already referenced in Wes Anderson’s Rushmore, however, so instead we get Largeman awkwardly trying to stay afloat in a pool despite not knowing how to swim — though perhaps not intentional, the inversion of this imagery is interesting to note.
Despite its themes, however, the film isn’t dour, sombre affair. Largeman’s interactions with people from his past is peppered with wry observations on the kinds of people who get older but never seem to grow out who they used to be. It reminded me, in some aspects, of Ted Demme’s Beautiful Girls (which is yet another film featuring Natalie Portman that I highly recommend) — there, too, old friends had never grown up or moved out, and so seemed doomed to play out the same role in different guises again and again.
Garden State is a film about a man learning to embrace life, and certainly gives Braff standing as someone other than simply the star of a quirky television comedy. His next directorial effort, a remake of the 2002 Dogme film Open Hearts, will be worth keeping an eye on.
Braff’s blog can be found here.